The Short Answer
If you want one pick and nothing else, take Heath Ledger in The Dark Knight (2008). Ledger built the character from posture, breath, and timing instead of paint, and the performance survives repeat viewings, which is the hardest test any Joker faces. Joaquin Phoenix in Joker (2019) is the strongest alternative if you prefer a slow psychological study over a crime thriller. Mark Hamill's voice work across Batman: The Animated Series is the best non-live-action take and the one most viewers grew up hearing. Every other Joker on this list is a supporting flavor, not a reason to commit two hours.
new update joker official site
How This Ranking Works
Ranking Jokers is not the same as ranking movies. A strong film can carry a forgettable Joker, and a weak film can still hold a memorable one. Four criteria do most of the work here.
- Screen time against impact. How much room the actor gets, and how much they do inside it.
- Physicality. Walk, laugh, stillness, and the way the character fills a frame.
- Writing support. Whether the script hands the performer a coherent arc or just punchlines.
- Durability. Whether the performance still lands ten or twenty years after release.
Parameter Bands To Keep In View
A lead Joker typically gets 40 to 60 minutes inside a two hour film. A supporting Joker often gets 15 to 25 minutes. A voice role can stretch across dozens of episodes and several hundred minutes of runtime. Do not rank a 20 minute supporting turn against a full lead performance without noting that gap, because the comparison flatters the smaller role for free.
recently updated site for joker
The Rankings
1. Heath Ledger, The Dark Knight (2008)
Ledger treats the role as a physical problem. The hunched shoulders, the licking of lips, the way he leans into a room instead of entering it. He also changes energy level scene to scene, so the character never becomes a single note. The Oscar for Best Supporting Actor was awarded after his death, and the performance has held up under two decades of imitation.
2. Joaquin Phoenix, Joker (2019)
Phoenix plays a man becoming the idea rather than a man who already is it, which makes him the most interior Joker on the list. The dance sequences and the weight loss read as commitment, though the film gives him a longer runway than any other actor gets. He won Best Actor for the role, and the performance works best when watched as a character study rather than a comic book adaptation.
3. Mark Hamill, Batman: The Animated Series (1992 to 1995)
Hamill has the deepest catalog of any Joker. He shifts between gleeful and genuinely menacing inside a single line, and the voice work influenced how a generation reads the character on the page. No makeup, no budget, just range and consistency across years of episodes.
4. Jack Nicholson, Batman (1989)
Nicholson plays the Joker as a mobster with a stage act, and the result is enormous fun. The performance loses points on menace, since he never feels unpredictable the way Ledger or Phoenix do, but the comic timing is the sharpest of any live-action version.
5. Cameron Monaghan, Gotham (2014 to 2019)
Two roles, one arc, and a slow slide that rewards anyone watching the series in order. Monaghan does more with network television constraints than the material should allow.
6. Cesar Romero, Batman (1966)
Romero refused to shave the mustache and the show painted over it, which tells you everything about the tone. Pure cartoon energy, and the template that Hamill later refined.
7. Barry Keoghan, The Batman (2022)
A short scene and a deleted scene, so the sample size is small. The energy is strange and unsettling, and it is a promising fragment rather than a finished performance.
8. Jared Leto, Suicide Squad (2016)
Heavy on tattoos and jewelry, light on threat. The theatrical cut gave him little to do, and even the extended version never settles on a clear read of the character.
Pitfalls To Avoid
- Confusing a good movie with a good performance. They are separate scores.
- Letting nostalgia decide. The version you saw at twelve is not automatically the best one.
- Judging a voice role by screen presence it was never meant to have.
- Ranking a cameo against a lead. Note the runtime before you compare.
- Rewarding prosthetics and weight change as proof of quality on their own.
FAQ
Which Joker performance should I start with?
Start with Ledger. If you want the psychological version afterward, move to Phoenix. If you want the version that shaped the comics audience, go to Hamill.
Is the animated Joker really comparable to live action?
Yes, if you compare craft instead of screen minutes. Voice acting carries the entire performance through tone and pace, with no wardrobe or camera work to hide behind.
Why does Jared Leto rank last?
Not because of effort, but because the released footage never gives him a coherent character to play. A ranking measures the finished product, not the intent.
Does winning an Oscar settle the debate?
No. Two Jokers have won Academy Awards and they win for different reasons. Awards confirm industry consensus, not a permanent verdict.